We’ve all got that one discontinued food we can’t stop thinking about. You know it’s probably not coming back, but you can’t help daydreaming about its unmatched taste. Even though you’ve tried similar things, nothing hits the spot in quite the same way – and maybe you’ve even considered starting a petition to bring it back. We’ve gathered some of the foods people miss most, from fast food to favorite snacks, to create the ultimate ranking.

Click or scroll through our gallery to see some of the most beloved discontinued products in America, counting down to the one everyone wants back.

Our ranking is based on thorough research into surveys and public opinion, on the enduring popularity of each discontinued item, and on the opinions of our expert team. This list is unavoidably subjective.

The discontinued foods Americans are most desperate to bring back